Totally get this. Been debating window upgrades myself, but the upfront costs keep making me pause... Did you notice savings pretty quickly, or was it more gradual? Thermostat tweaks help, but windows seem like the bigger win long-term.
Did the windows about two years ago when refinancing let us pull some equity out, and I'd say the savings were noticeable but definitely gradual. First few months, I was kinda skeptical because the bills didn't drop dramatically right away. But over the seasons, especially winter and summer, you notice the house stays comfortable without constantly fiddling with the thermostat. Thermostat tweaks help, sure, but windows make the house hold that temp better overall.
One thing I learned: check if your state or energy company offers rebates or tax credits for window upgrades. We got a decent rebate that took some sting out of the initial cost. Also, consider phased upgrades—maybe doing upstairs first or just the most problematic windows could ease your budget concerns.
Curious though, have you looked into how much adding insulation factors into all this? I've heard mixed reviews about insulation vs windows for overall energy savings...
We did insulation in the attic about a year before tackling windows, and honestly, the insulation seemed to make a quicker difference in heating bills. But windows definitely improved comfort more noticeably over time, especially drafts and noise reduction. Have you thought about getting an energy audit done first? Might help pinpoint exactly where your biggest energy leaks are before committing to one or the other...
Interesting point about insulation vs windows. I've done both, and honestly, I noticed the thermostat upgrade made a surprising difference too. Have you considered a smart thermostat yet? I was skeptical at first—thought it was just another gadget—but it actually learned our schedule pretty quickly and adjusted heating automatically. Saved us a decent chunk on bills without even thinking about it.
But yeah, windows definitely improved comfort more noticeably, especially if you're dealing with noise or drafts. An energy audit is a solid suggestion though...I had one done, and turns out my biggest leak was actually around the doors, not windows or attic insulation. Go figure, right? Maybe your biggest savings could come from somewhere unexpected too.
Totally agree on the smart thermostat—it's surprising how much it helps once it figures out your routine. I was pretty skeptical too, but now I wouldn't go back. One thing I'd add though: sealing up those smaller leaks around outlets and baseboards made a noticeable difference for us. Not as flashy as new windows, but cheap and easy enough to tackle yourself on a weekend...worth checking out if you haven't already.