does a single paint chip really matter if the house is solid otherwise?
I hear you on that—sometimes it feels like the VA’s checklist is more about boxes than actual safety. I’ve had deals stall over tiny things like a missing handrail or a cracked window pane, even when the bones of the place were great. Still, I get why they do it. Those little issues can add up, and for first-time buyers especially, it’s better to have every detail checked. Frustrating in the moment, but it does save headaches down the line.
I get where you’re coming from—sometimes it feels nitpicky, like the process is more about appearances than real issues. But I’ve also seen those “minor” things turn into bigger headaches for buyers later, especially if they’re not handy or don’t have cash to fix stuff right away. I do wonder, though, are there any parts of the VA requirements people find truly useful, or is it mostly just red tape?
Honestly, I get frustrated with the VA requirements too, especially when it feels like they’re nitpicking stuff that doesn’t seem like a big deal. But looking back, I’m actually kind of grateful for some of it. When we refinanced, the inspector caught a leak under the sink I’d totally missed. It was a pain to fix in the moment, but if it had gone unnoticed, it probably would’ve cost way more down the line.
I do think some of the rules are just hoops to jump through—like the chipped paint thing on an old garage, which felt a little overkill. But I guess if you’re not super handy or don’t want surprise expenses right after moving in, there’s some peace of mind knowing the basics are covered. It’s annoying in the short term, but maybe not all bad in the long run.
Step 1: Get ready for a wild ride—VA appraisers have eagle eyes. I totally get what you mean about the “chipped paint thing.”
But hey, I’ve seen a deal almost fall apart over a patch of missing paint the size of a quarter. Not joking.I do think some of the rules are just hoops to jump through—like the chipped paint thing on an old garage, which felt a little overkill.
Step 2: If you spot anything that looks like it belongs in a “before” photo, fix it ahead of time. Saves a lot of back and forth.
Step 3: Remember, the VA’s just trying to make sure you’re not buying a money pit. Annoying? Yes. But at least nobody’s moving in with a surprise indoor swimming pool under the kitchen sink...
VA Loan Appraisal Surprises: Chipped Paint & Other Gotchas
Totally agree with the “eagle eyes” comment—VA appraisers really do catch things most buyers (and even agents) would miss. That chipped paint rule? It’s not just old garages, either. I’ve seen them flag a single window sill with a tiny flake missing. Feels nitpicky, but it’s about lead paint risk, especially on homes built before 1978.
A few quick pointers I always give clients:
- Check for any exposed wood or peeling paint, inside and out. Even sheds and fences.
- Handrails are a biggie—missing on stairs? That’ll get flagged.
- Roofs need to have “reasonable life left.” If it looks rough, expect questions.
- Utilities must be on and functional during the appraisal. No power = no pass.
- Water stains or signs of leaks? Fix those up front, or you’ll be scrambling later.
“I do think some of the rules are just hoops to jump through—like the chipped paint thing on an old garage, which felt a little overkill.”
It does feel like overkill sometimes, but I’ve seen deals delayed for weeks over stuff like this. Prepping ahead saves so much hassle. The VA isn’t trying to make life hard—they just want to avoid surprises... though sometimes it feels like they’re looking for them!
