Mortgages discussions and local services.

DITCHING THAT PESKY MORTGAGE INSURANCE - WORTH THE HASSLE?

240 replies 17.8 K views
 
mobile_steven
22 posts

Totally get that sense of relief you're talking about - it's like finally getting rid of an annoying roommate who eats your snacks, right? 😂 But here's something I've wondered: for those who've refinanced to ditch PMI, did you factor in the closing costs against the monthly savings? I mean, sure, dropping PMI feels amazing, but did anyone crunch the numbers to see how long it took to break even on those closing expenses? Curious if anyone found a sweet spot timing-wise... or maybe just went with their gut and hoped for the best (been there, done that).


Reply
amandarunner627
14 posts

"did anyone crunch the numbers to see how long it took to break even on those closing expenses?"

Yeah, I ran the numbers when I refinanced a few years back. Honestly, it took longer than I initially expected - almost 3 years - to hit that break-even point. Felt like forever at first, but looking back, I'm glad I took the cautious route. Anyone else find the savings weren't quite as immediate as they hoped, or was it just me being overly cautious again...?


Reply
vr_holly
22 posts

I remember doing the math myself when I refinanced to ditch PMI a while back. Thought I'd be swimming in savings right away, but nope - took me about two and a half years just to break even on closing costs. Felt like watching paint dry at first, honestly. Still, once I crossed that line, it was nice seeing the monthly payment shrink a bit. Guess patience really is key with these things...


Reply
hollyw60
23 posts

Did you factor in how long you planned to stay in the home when you did your math? A lot of folks overlook that part. PMI can be annoying, sure, but refinancing isn't always the best move if you're thinking of selling or moving soon. For me, it was about 3 years before I saw any real savings, but I knew I'd be sticking around for at least 5-7 years, so it made sense. Did you run those numbers too, or just focus on ditching PMI?


Reply
21 posts

Yeah, good point about the timeline - people often skip that step. When I refinanced to drop PMI, I initially just wanted the monthly payment relief, but after crunching numbers realized I'd only break even after about 2.5 years. Since I planned to stay put at least another 4-5, it worked out in my favor. It's definitely worth taking a moment to run the numbers rather than jumping in just to ditch PMI...


Reply

Join the conversation

Share your experience or ask a follow-up question.

Scroll to Top