Notifications
Clear all

How tough is it to get a mortgage for a rental if your credit isn’t perfect?

293 Posts
281 Users
0 Reactions
9,046 Views
afire37
Posts: 22
(@afire37)
Eminent Member
Joined:

“Honestly, the process feels invasive at times, but it’s not personal—they’re just covering their bases.”

Yeah, “invasive” is putting it mildly. When I refinanced last year, I swear they wanted everything short of my childhood report cards. Here’s what helped me:

- Keep a digital folder—scan *everything* ahead of time. You’ll thank yourself later.
- Don’t stress about a single credit blip if you’ve got steady income and can explain things.
- Agree on the letters of explanation—sounds silly, but a quick note about that weird deposit really does smooth things over.
- If you’re married, brace yourself for double the paperwork. My spouse was not amused.

It’s a pain, but not impossible. Just gotta jump through a few more hoops...


Reply
Posts: 9
(@jerryc10)
Active Member
Joined:

I hear you on the paperwork overload. When I tried for a rental mortgage last fall, I felt like I was prepping for an audit, not buying property. My credit isn’t spotless—had a late payment from a medical bill—and I was sure it’d tank my chances. Turns out, the lender mostly wanted proof I could handle the extra debt. They grilled me about every side gig deposit, but once I explained stuff (with those letters you mentioned), it wasn’t a dealbreaker. Still, the process made me rethink every random Venmo transfer... If you’re organized and upfront, they seem more willing to work with you than I expected.


Reply
Posts: 22
(@zeus_dreamer)
Eminent Member
Joined:

I get what you’re saying about being upfront, but honestly, I’ve seen lenders get really picky if your credit isn’t close to spotless—especially with investment properties. Did you have to put down a bigger deposit? In my experience, they’ll sometimes ask for 25% or more just to offset the risk. The paperwork is wild, but I’ve also had underwriters come back with new questions weeks later, just when I thought I’d answered everything... ever run into that?


Reply
lisathomas657
Posts: 19
(@lisathomas657)
Active Member
Joined:

The paperwork is wild, but I’ve also had underwriters come back with new questions weeks later, just when I thought I’d answered everything... ever run into that?

Totally, the paperwork treadmill is real. Had an underwriter ask for proof of a $200 deposit from two years back—felt like overkill. Bigger down payment's almost a given if your credit isn’t pristine. It’s frustrating, but hang in there; persistence pays off.


Reply
streamer42
Posts: 16
(@streamer42)
Active Member
Joined:

Honestly, I don’t think a bigger down payment is always a given if your credit’s not perfect. Depends a lot on the lender and how you present your finances. I’ve seen folks with mid-600s scores get decent terms just by showing strong rental income history or solid reserves. The paperwork is nuts, yeah, but sometimes it’s about how you organize everything upfront—makes the underwriter’s job easier and cuts down on those random requests. Not saying it’s ever smooth, but it’s not always as grim as it sounds.


Reply
Page 52 / 59
Share:
Scroll to Top